Rules-Based PortfoliosRanked by Performance

Rules-based portfolios follow a systematic, pre-defined process for making investment decisions -- such as when to buy, sell, or rebalance -- without relying on discretionary judgment. The rules might be based on technical signals, valuation metrics, momentum indicators, or macroeconomic conditions, but the key feature is that they are applied consistently regardless of market sentiment or short-term noise.

By removing emotion and discretion from the investment process, rules-based strategies aim to avoid the behavioral biases that cause many investors to buy high and sell low. The tradeoff is rigidity: a rules-based system will continue following its process even when it seems obviously wrong in the moment, which can produce extended periods of underperformance when market conditions fall outside the strategy's design parameters. Understanding the logic behind the rules helps investors stick with the strategy when it struggles.

PortfolioCAGRMax DrawdownSharpeWorst YearRisk
Defensive Asset Allocation by Keller and Keuning13.7%-16.6%0.98-8.4%2/5
Vigilant Asset Allocation - G4 Aggressive16.1%-16.9%0.92-8.7%2/5
Generalized Protective Momentum12.0%-9.9%0.88-3.2%1/5
Vigilant Asset Allocation - G1211.6%-21.4%0.87-9.7%2/5
Protective Asset Allocation by Keller and Keuning11.9%-20.6%0.86-16.5%2/5
Composite Dual Momentum11.5%-13.5%0.82-9.7%2/5
GEM Dual Momentum14.5%-21.6%0.79-17.2%2/5
Diversified GEM Dual Momentum13.1%-19.8%0.74-17.5%2/5
Kipnis Defensive Adaptive Asset Allocation11.0%-10.6%0.74-3.4%1/5
Robust Asset Allocation - Balanced9.6%-12.0%0.74-4.4%1/5
Accelerating Dual Momentum14.3%-25.8%0.71-24.2%3/5
Stoken's Active Combined Asset (ACA)11.5%-24.7%0.71-22.7%3/5
Quint Switching Filtered12.2%-26.6%0.68-15.2%3/5
Robust Asset Allocation - Aggressive10.1%-15.5%0.65-7.3%2/5
Adaptive Asset Allocation10.8%-15.6%0.64-11.4%2/5
Three-Way Model by Ned Davis11.5%-24.9%0.59-14.7%3/5
GEM + Emerging Markets Dual Momentum12.8%-22.1%0.59-19.4%3/5
Paired Switching by Lewis Glenn10.8%-30.8%0.52-23.1%3/5

Sorted by Sharpe ratio (highest to lowest). All stats backtested from inception. See methodology →